What can you negotiate in a contract? Tips to help you get creative with counter offers by Phyllis Maguire
Published in the June 2008 issue of Today's Hospitalist
When it comes to what’s negotiable in a job offer, there are items to which even doctor-strapped hospitalist groups will say “no." Regina Levison, a West Coast recruiter, recalls one physician who interviewed for a full-time job with a private group. But he still had a part-time project he needed to finish up—on another continent. He tried to negotiate having the group pick up the tab for airfare for himself and his family once a month for several months.
“Make one list of items you want to negotiate and do it at one time.”
–Regina Levison Levison Search Associates
client said ‘no,’ but the physician ended up working with the group anyway,” says Ms. Levison, president of Levison Search Associates in El Dorado, Calif.
In the overheated job market for hospitalists, it can be difficult for physicians to know exactly how far they can push during negotiations. Compensation keeps growing by leaps and bounds, and so do the perks being offered to hospitalists.
“Nothing is sacrosanct,” says Susan Edson, vice president of New England Health Search, which is based in Orono, Maine. “The common denominator is that everybody is offering more.”
That doesn’t mean, however, that your strategy should be to take whatever you’re offered and demand 20% more. As Ms. Levison’s story illustrates, even hospitalists face some limits in what they can ask for.
Here’s a look at what can—and can’t—be negotiated in today’s job market.
Making the most of compensation
Compensation offers are now caught in a tug-of-war between surging hospitalist salaries—pay has risen 13% in the last two years, according to one recent survey—and the need to maintain parity and goodwill with physicians already in the group.
That’s why if you’re looking at a job with a larger group that has established physicians, the base pay may be pretty much set in stone. If you’re looking at a new practice that needs to hire its first “seed” physicians, on the other hand, you’ll probably see more flexibility regarding pay.
Geography also plays a part in how much you can negotiate salaries, says Ms. Edson, who represents community hospitals throughout New England. Her part of the country tends to have lower reimbursements than hospitals and groups in the South or Midwest, she reports. While rural hospitals really need to find hospitalists, they are often limited in what they can pay.
“All of a sudden, we’re talking $180,000 in this market just to be competitive,” Ms. Edson says, “and somebody with experience can certainly get more,” possibly up to $190,000. “That’s starting to sound like a lot of money for a staff position. As far as salary, there is not that much wiggle room.”
Ms. Levison notes that geography also plays a role in keeping physicians’ base pay lower on the West Coast. In part, that’s because doctors who want West Coast locations are willing to work for less than they would receive in other parts of the country.
In addition, practice setting affects the range in which compensation can be negotiated. “In an urban or suburban hospital, there is plenty of volume,” which can increase reimbursement, Ms. Levison points out. “That’s often not the case in small or rural communities where reimbursement may be higher but patient volume is lower.”
Another factor that affects your room to negotiate salary: the size of the practice or program. Generally speaking, say recruiters, the smaller the group, the easier it is for a practice to be creative with compensation, benefits and scheduling.
Sweetening the deal
The good news is that even practices that don’t have a lot of leeway in terms of salary can find ways to sweeten the pot. Recruits can negotiate more in terms of a signing bonus—an incentive, recruiters say, that you need to ask for and not expect to be automatically offered.
Or candidates can increasingly negotiate a healthier-than-usual relocation package, allowing them to cover their relocation expenses and sometimes pocket the difference. “That’s an area,” Ms. Edson points out, “where groups can become creative for sure.”
Even a group that has not historically paid its physicians a signing bonus might offer one if the group is suddenly caught short-staffed. While the doctors already there may not have enjoyed the same sign-on bonus, they’ll probably be more than amenable to doing whatever it takes to get a doctor on board quickly.
Likewise, those same physicians won’t mind if a new doctor is paid a bit more generously to take a larger share of night shifts. That’s why recruiters offer the following advice: If you’re feeling hemmed in by what’s been given to the other physicians in the group, take note of any special circumstances—the hospitalist who’s already given notice to take a pulmonary fellowship, for instance—and use it to your advantage.
A new twist on loans and mortgages
Another area where hospitalist programs may put together a better package is student loans.
According to Ms. Edson, loan repayment has become a “very important incentive tool” throughout New England and one that is changing.
Historically, she says, clients paid a physician’s loans for only three or five years, as long as the doctor was still working there. “Now I’m hearing, ‘We will pay back all your loans for as long as it takes, as long as you stay here,’ which I didn’t hear even two years ago.”
One of her clients even goes so far as to pay all of a physician’s school loans in one lump sum at the very beginning of a contract. But that, she says, is rare.
On the West Coast, by comparison, Ms. Levison says loan repayment isn’t a standard incentive. More frequently, it a strategy used to entice physicians to underserved areas.
And while help with a mortgage is another perk that is growing in popularity, not every practice can offer it. Ms. Edson says that because her clients are hospitals and not private groups, they are constrained by the Stark anti-kickback regulations from offering potential employees help with a new or existing mortgage.
Problems selling homes, says Ms. Edson, are having a growing impact on hospitalist recruiting. Physicians looking to relocate are finding that they can’t sell a house in the area they wish to leave, and they certainly don’t want to carry two mortgages. On the flip side, Ms. Levison points out that the down economy may be a good opportunity for physicians to get into a high-priced housing market—like the West Coast—with a more reasonable mortgage.
Non-competes and tail coverage
Recruiters give different reports on whether non-compete clauses (in those states where they are enforceable) can be negotiated.
According to Ms. Edson, her hospital clients have template contracts in which non-competes can’t be negotiated away.
But other recruiters say that some practices—particularly larger ones—may start out offering candidates a standard contract. But the groups may consider changing the terms, by either dropping the clause up-front or agreeing to rescind it after a certain number of years of service.
Another item to consider negotiating for is tail coverage. Many hospitals and groups now offer tail coverage as a recruiting incentive. But if you’re leaving a practice that does not offer tail coverage, ask your potential employer or group if it would contribute. To seal the deal, groups may either pay all the tail of the practice that you’re leaving; pay a portion of it, leaving you to pay the rest; or give you a salary advance to help you to pay the tail up-front.
While recruiters encourage physicians to get the best package possible, they also point out that some styles of negotiating definitely raise a red flag. Even groups desperate for hospitalists shy away from a physician who, for instance, wants to rewrite every detail in the job offer. Some styles of negotiating, recruiters say, are so aggressive that recruits come off as paranoid, greedy or high-maintenance, and even under-staffed practices will pull a job offer off the table.
Remember too, says Ms. Edson, that “it’s never smart to ask for things in the first interview.” Your first visit should be a meet-and-greet and a fact-gathering mission, she adds. Start discussing bonuses and other items after that first visit, and wait for the group or employer to mention terms first.
When you’re having an attorney look over a contract, be sure to negotiate enough time to get a response. “A job offer may require you to respond within 10 days,” Ms. Levison explains. “If that’s not long enough to have the contract reviewed by your attorney, arrange an extension.”
Ms. Levison offers another cardinal rule about negotiating terms: Go to the well only once.
“When you keep coming back a third or a fourth time with more changes you want, the practice feels like its being nickeled and dimed,” she says.
Every time you want to renegotiate, that request has to be vetted and discussed within the practice and with its attorneys. “Groups don’t appreciate that.” Instead, Ms. Levison says, “make one list of items you want to negotiate and do it at one time.” She has seen groups that, after being subjected to too many negotiating cycles, just “wash their hands and withdraw the offer.”
Phyllis Maguire is Executive Editor of Today’s Hospitalist.
Too much attention to the bottom line—or too little?
While it’s important to negotiate the best package possible, Susan Edson, vice president of New England Health Search, a New England recruiting firm, says that doctors need to keep some perspective during the contracting process: It’s not all about the money.
“It’s too bad when physicians just look at the bottom line, because there’s certainly more to a job than that,” Ms. Edson says. “It’s also about community and colleagues.”
Recruiters complain that too many young recruits make the mistake of not listening hard enough to potential earnings or other details about the job and location. Many physicians focus exclusively on first-year earnings, for instance, and don’t pay attention to what they may be able to make over the next three to five years.
Or they make the opposite mistake: not paying enough attention to a prospective group’s management and business practices. That’s particularly an issue, points out Regina Levison, president of Levison Search Associates, a recruiting firm in El Dorado, Calif., when you’re considering an offer from a private or multispecialty group.
“If the management of the group and the billing piece are a mess,” Ms. Levison says, “doctors working there are going to make less money.” While you should still negotiate the best terms you can, it’s important to meet with the group administrator and billing manager during the interview process to look over financial statements. That will help protect you against joining a group that may potentially have trouble meeting payroll.